Final Assessment Off Cuts

I don’t think this is going to make it’s way into the final assessment script which is a shame. BUT! Nothing is wasted when you have a blog so here we go:

“How do the methods used to generate formal academic knowledge effect it’s representation in digital network media?”

We’re going to look at two apps, Litlong and Curious Edinburgh. Now ostensibly they are representing formal academic knowledge in a very similar manner. They are both apps for mobile phones that add content markers to a GPS map of Edinburgh. However, if you look at them in detail we find that there are vast differences between the apps. I will argue that the cause of these dissimilarities is the different methods the app developers used to generate their formal academic knowledge. From this we can conclude that is important to avoid making instrumentalist conclusions about what methods are used for generating knowledge. In turn, this will reinforce why it is vital to take a critical approach technologies in Education which looks at the wider social practice of a technologies production.

How are they similar?

GENERATE Both are content based apps as they give access to large amounts of data with no assessment or learning task built in. Cherner et al.

GENERATE Both are manipulable – Goodwin and Highfield 2012 no set structure in the order, time or place you access the information. Counters perception of algorithmic/digital culture being committed to procedure.

GENERATE Both required inter-disciplinary approach to their production – interdiscplinary algorthmists relate to interdisciplinary approach of both apps

For a single academic, or even a single department, to produce these apps they would need to be well versed in computer science, data analysis, English Literature, History, Sociology and so on. Far too much for any one person to be an expert in all the requisite fields. This means that the apps had to be produced by an interdisciplinary approach.

The example of these apps provide a possible answer to a question posed by William, namely, should academics learn to code to transmit knowledge? These apps seems to suggest they should just head teams who do the coding for them.


What causes the differences between the apps?

I would argue that the differences between the two apps are caused primarily by the way formal academic knowledge is generated and represented. The developers generated different academic knowledge as they are from different disciplines. This means they would have different ideas about what the content of the apps should be. We can critique this using some of the same methods that Tarleton Gillespie uses to critique algorithms. Specifically, we need to ask how the developers addressed:

  1. Patterns of inclusion
  2. Evaluation of relevance
  3. Entanglement with practice

So LitLong had a very broad pattern of inclusion. As long as the text excerpt found by the algorithm could be mapped onto a location in Edinburgh it was included. Every excerpt that managed this was deemed to be relevant. The workshops with different groups showed the varying ways the app could be entangled with practice.

In contrast, Curious Edinburgh’s pattern of inclusion was far narrower. The locations mapped had to be of verifiable significance to the history of science. The evaluation of relevance was carried out by the academic team drawing upon their knowledge of the field of the history of science. These academics were also in a position of institutional power to ensure it the usage of the app entangled with their student’s practice by making it part of a formal assessment.


What this analysis of the two apps shows is that you can take what on the surface seems like a similar approach and end up with very different ways of representing formal academic knowledge. For me the most significant differences between the two apps were how they were used (in workshops, formal assessments) and the levels of funding they had to produce the apps (with subsequent responsibilities the teams had to their benefactors). These differences were caused by the way the developers chose to generate and represent their knowledge. What is crucial for our understanding of how digital networked media can be used to formulate this kind of knowledge is to consider the social context in which they are made and used. This in turn reinforces the importance of the critical approach taken to Education and Digital Cultures throughout this cours

87 thoughts on “Final Assessment Off Cuts”

  1. Открылся новый магазин все по 50 рублей, например определенный товар стоит 5000 рублей или 7000 рублей то у нас вы можете найти его всего за 50 рублей:
    магазин ежедневно пополняется, к концу недели будет очень богатый ассортимент.

  2. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon!

  3. Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results. If you know of any please share. Appreciate it!

  4. Wonderful article sir. an excellent information given by you during this blog. It really informative and really helpful. Keep posting are going to be expecting your next blog.Thank you

  5. [url=]dapoxetine[/url] [url=]buy metformin online[/url] [url=]no prescription cialis[/url] [url=]vardenafil 20mg tablets[/url] [url=]synthroid[/url]

  6. [url=]furosemide drug[/url] [url=]buy ventolin online[/url] [url=]augmentin 250 mg tablets[/url] [url=]buy lisinopril[/url] [url=]elimite buy online[/url] [url=]buy cozaar 50 mg[/url] [url=]buy citalopram[/url] [url=]buy albuterol[/url]

  7. Shandong Lijian Cnc Machinery Co.,Ltd LJMC&cncbusbarmachinesupplybest2020 mainly for CNC busbar punching and cutting machine,CNC busbar bending machines,CNC busbar milling machines,CNC turrent busbar processing machine,busbar levelling machines etc.Products are widely used in high and low voltage complete sets, switch cabinet,box substation,transformer,busbar duct line etc.
    copper busbar cutting machine

  8. The cleaning company carries out cleaning of spaces of different dimensions and also arrangements.

    We provide professional maid service agency for personal customers. Utilizing European devices and also licensed tools, we attain maximum outcomes as well as offer cleaning in a short time.

    The company’s professionals supply cleaning with the aid of contemporary innovations, have special tools, and likewise have accredited detergents in their collection. Along with the above advantages, white wines supply: beneficial rates; cleaning in a short time; excellent quality outcomes; greater than 100 favorable reviews. Cleansing offices will assist keep your office in order for the most effective job. Any kind of business is extremely important ambience in the group. Cleaning services that can be purchased cheaply now can aid to organize it and also provide a comfy room for labor.

    If essential, we leave cleansing the kitchen 2-3 hours after placing the order. You get cleansing as soon as possible.

    We provide discount rates for those that use the service for the very first time, along with beneficial terms of participation for normal clients.

    We supply high-quality cleaning for large enterprises and also small companies of various instructions, with a price cut of up to 25%.

    Our friendly team uses you to obtain accustomed with desirable regards to teamwork for company clients. We properly approach our activities, clean making use of specialist cleaning items and specific devices. Our staff members are trained, have clinical books and are familiar with the subtleties of getting rid of complicated as well as hard-to-remove dirt from surface areas.

  9. Add some grass, hay or straw to the natural bowl and let your pet munch away.Place the practical Natural Woven Grass Bed inside your pet’s cage to protect its sensitive paws from the hard, wire bottom of the his or her happy home.Woven grass play ball is the ultimate in natural grass toys that are safe to chew and provide hours of entertainment for your pet.
    grass finch nests

  10. Hello there, I found your blog by the use of Google at the same time as
    searching for a similar matter, your web site came up, it looks good.
    I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

    Hi there, simply turned into aware of your blog via Google,
    and found that it is truly informative. I’m gonna watch out for brussels.

    I will appreciate for those who proceed this in future.
    Many folks will be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!
    adreamoftrains content hosting

  11. When I initially commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time
    a comment is added I get three emails with the same
    comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that service?
    Many thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *