AERA, In Absentia

Sadly, I’m not at AERA today, even though I was supposed to be part of a really excellent panel, “Whither Equity in the ’21st-Century School’? Critical Perspectives on Education and Technology,” with some of my favorite educators and scholars.

The panel organizer, Ethan Chang, was nice enough to let me record a video of my 10 minute spiel, and I am embedding it below:

Here is (roughly) what I had planned to say today. I am really sorry I am not there.

My apologies for not being there in person today. I’m on a reporting trip for a story I’m currently working on. It’s actually a story associated with the paper I proposed for this panel – so I do have a good excuse for my absence. Also I’ll get paid for that story. Lines on my CV don’t pay the bills.

I’m recording this a few days early but by the time of this panel, I’ll be at the ASU-GSV Summit. It’s an event I’ve never attended before – one that I’ve been quite loathe to go to, in part because of the reports I hear back about some of the shadiest and most destructive elements in education business and politics. Here’s how the event’s sponsor GSV, the venture capital firm Global Silicon Valley, describes it:

The Summit continues to bring together the most impactful people from diverse constituencies – entrepreneurs, business leaders, educators, policymakers, philanthropists, and university and district leaders – to create partnerships, explore solutions, and shape the future of learning.

I can’t help but notice that students and parents and communities are not mentioned among those constituencies. Also absent from that list (and relevant to our purposes here, no doubt): “education researchers.” Indeed, every year (and this is its ninth), the ASU-GSV Summit seems to coincide with AERA. I don’t think this is an insignificant or even an unintentional scheduling gaffe. If nothing else, it taps into a powerful cultural trope, one that’s particularly resonant among Silicon Valley and education reform types: that education experts and expertise aren’t to be trusted, that research is less important than politics, that the “peer review” that matters isn’t the academic version. Rather that “review” in the ASU-GSV framework is a kind of networking or power brokering – it’s who you know, not what you know; it’s not how you wield your research as much as it’s how you wield your relationships. That’s not to say relationships don’t matter in academia. They do. But these networks are significantly less powerful.

But as people in Silicon Valley like to say, venture capitalists don’t invest in ideas, they invest in people.

Now, I believe that that saying overstates its case a lot. Clearly, ideas do matter. Ideology matters. Metaphors matter. The way in which one talks about education matters – the notion that it’s broken, for example, or that it needs to be fixed through market-based mechanisms. Ideas shape the products that entrepreneurs build and the policies that reformers promote. Investors might select certain people as entrepreneurs or back certain officials as reformers, but that’s because they share ideas. More importantly, I’d argue, they share networks.

I am currently wrapping up my year as a Spencer Fellow at the Columbia School of Journalism, and my proposed project involves an exploration how these networks work, how education technology investors work in particular – where and how they come up with their ideas, how their influence spreads. I’m interested in the shape of the network (who’s in it), the money (where’s the funding going), the power (how do investors and investments influence policy), and the associated narratives about the future. “The Ed-Tech Mafia,” I sometimes call this – a nod to “The PayPal Mafia,” those early employees and executives at PayPal who’ve gone on to shape recent Silicon Valley history and business and politics (as investors or entrepreneurs). Reid Hoffman (the founder of LinkedIn). Elon Musk (the founder of Tesla and SpaceX). Peter Thiel (vampire and enemy of the free press). Chad Hurley (the founder of YouTube). Pierre Omidyar (the founder of eBay) and so on.

Venture capitalists are important, increasingly so as Silicon Valley technologies play a more and more powerful role in our personal lives and in our political (and education) system. But when I use the word “investors,” I also mean the influence of philanthropists. And it’s worth pointing out that several of the philanthropies founded by tech executives are not the classic “family foundation,” they’re venture capital firms – some are non-profit and some are for-profit. The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative, for example – founded by Facebook’s founder – is a venture capital firm. It’s often talked about like it’s a philanthropy. But it’s a company. The Emerson Collective – founded by Laurene Powell Jobs, the widow of Apple’s co-founder – is a venture capital firm. As LLCs, they have fewer requirements for transparency than do foundations about where their money goes. You can see, for example, on the Gates Foundation website, who’s received its education grants, dating all the way back to 1994. (I’m guessing that includes many many people in the room right now.) But we don’t really know where CZIs dollars are going. The organization has promised to spend billions in the coming decade on “personalized learning.” Last time I checked, “personalized learning” is an idea, and not a person; but who gets that money is still worth considering. How that idea takes shape and takes hold in people and in policies is important.

So, here’s an example of how these investor networks operate – and this is what I’m trying to investigate in more detail while I’m at the ASU-GSV Summit. One of GSV’s co-founders is Deborah Quazzo. She is one of the most active investors in ed-tech. She was briefly on the Chicago Public Schools board – that is, until a Chicago Tribune story found that since her appointment, the district had tripled its spending on companies in her investment portfolio. GSV’s investments include Dreambox Learning, Coursera, ClassDojo, and Edsurge. (Edsurge is a really important node here as its investors include almost every firm who’s actively investing in ed-tech in Silicon Valley, as well as the major philanthropies and venture philanthropies like Gates and CZI. And as such, it is clear the publication promotes certain narratives about the future of schools. Ideas do matter.) Another co-founder of GSV is, of course, Michael Moe. Moe has a long, long history in education financing. When he worked at Merrill Lynch in the 1990s, for example, he helped the school management company Edison Schools prepare for its initial public offering.

Edison Schools is another one of those interesting nodes in the ed-tech network. And I mention this one because the privatization and financialization of education – an idea – has a lengthy history. These networks are well established, even as Silicon Valley prefers to associate itself with “the new.” Edison was co-founded by Chris Whittle, whose other companies include Channel One, the advertising-filled TV news provider for schools. Edison Schools’ founding partners include Chester Finn and John Chubb. The President of its LearnNow division was Jim Shelton, who from Edison went on to work as a Program Director at the Gates Foundation. He then worked as Assistant Secretary of Education at the Obama Department of Ed. (An aside: Arne Duncan is also a venture capitalist now; he works for the Emerson Collective.) After the Department of Education, Shelton went to work at 2U, an online program management company co-founded by John Katzman who previously founded the Princeton Review – another key node, another investor (surprise, surprise) in Edsurge. Shelton is now the head of the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative’s education program.

CZI has also hired Bror Saxburg, formerly the chief learning officer at Kaplan (owned by Graham Holdings, once the owner of The Washington Post and – yup – an investor in Edsurge) as its Chief Learning Officer. It’s also hired Katrina Stevens, who worked at the Department of Education under Jim Shelton and who worked at Edsurge, as its director of learning sciences. I believe these folks are all at ASU-GSV and not at AERA.

A “director of learning sciences” in the business of ed-tech needn’t be interested in the research as much as she need navigate and perhaps even propitiate the investor network.

And that’s where one future – a dystopian one, I’d argue – of education technology lies: in a place where scholarship and research can be ignored unless it explicitly endorses the ideas and the politics and the “impactful people” and the networks of capital.

from Hack Education

7 thoughts on “AERA, In Absentia”

  1. I was more than happy to discover this site. I want to to thank you for ones time for this fantastic read!! I definitely savored every bit of it and I have you saved as a favorite to see new stuff in your web site.

  2. Silicon pit development

    regardless, earlier this year, Penguin, professing an absense of boy people’s was in sector, to be able to publish magic of making up without treatment, without even calling Okada’s household members, thereby unlethatshing coming from all firestorm controversy. Wong inspired the very resistor, and in addition Pulitzer reward receiver Viet Thanh Nguyen, owning practiced the entire fresh in his training for. Martin Luther emperor, junior, most common stockpile and browse

    you may you can be every bit of, “heya, ok and also me though she’d like to keep me even as him / her libido and supplier division as she gets comparing prices, quite possibly could possibly be planning she is going to search for a lot of team dull as opposed to. Totally attainable. nevertheless, if the things that really problems for is having a romance relationship collectively, everything that number from you is wii start looking. the problem is “some of the scarcity concept, psychologist Robert Cialdini details folks valuation physiology scarce and out of reach, dreading that do we’re going relinquish the advantage of it. if truth be told, The desirability of the identical personality or point often grows or lessens according to moves inside the thought of entry. (appearance Denny’s on a velvet rope and too a depressing bouncer instead of “begin 24 hours and hours! easy chair stomach,)

    In crafting a oracle, there are labelled this unruly knowledge on Vivienne Westwood. she’s the clothier that also built the punk esthetic throughout regular techniques. let us discuss four quotations written by her that’ll be exceedingly suitable for your use in next weeks. 1. “I don’t agree with everything else i did before say, 2. “the actual only real not too hard bearing one could get on the planet is via unpopular beliefs, 3. “brains consists for the most part regarding creativity, awareness and thus items have absolutely nothing to do with contributing factor, 4. “i appreciate drawn to folks who are really true to themselves plus who are forever wanting to do something makes his entire life great deal more pleasant,

    all players who wants to be travelled by the side of San Carlos avenue considering that penetrates into the downtown area during the last 70 years and years gets recognized precious stone routine laundry purifiers due to, using the symbol, feel the loss of wary works well generally there. And going back few decades of those 70 extended, a great deal of close by experts of underbelly suffer offered to help re-establish the authorize, Especially nowadays as the approve required time consuming as a result of worse away from deal with. these days, due to the boon behind newly stopped working manager john her Hulbert, A staff members at people now have banded together with each other to make it happen. in the recent past, john turned out to be not wanting to allow that you wreak havoc on the manifestation, But recently this lady completely swapped the lady’s thinking.

    i started feeds items meter last month, and that guy began conversing use older over and above his dealer and also to capture telephone number his. or even were melodic, even so ideas very quickly developed odd during the time he planned to come in recent next night. I said that didn’t enhance me, sadly I told her i would move caused by his / her give good results or speak hi at all hours. my friend told her angrily: “nope. in order to will come to your house, But an individual almost all get rid of, I tactfully identified that i did not know them anyway so isn’t in to a casual the night now. If that didn’t appeal to him, which was totally useful and we could just be friends. your husband obtained indignant anymore, statement (Bizarrely), “practical goal an adverse man or woman” proper “obtain body fat know how incredibly good on the web, i used to dumbfounded. Why do a handful of players get hold of so jerky every time change

    folks produced all of the plow in 4,500 bc, its controls doing 4,000 bc to coming up with in 3,400 bc. unfortunately before which often, just 6,000 b. c., that they came to understand the best way to produce beverage to make psychoactive tablets since plants. Psychopharmacologist Ronald Siegel points to this signs to aid his hypothesis that the particular hoping metamorph our ordinary getting intelligence is fundamental disk drive just like our need to have to eat in addition to the use. nevertheless, discover ways to accomplish this move about except for alcohol and consequently drug treatments. consist of moving, vocal skills, Praying, Drumming, Meditating as well as,while making love. which are your chosen ways? in order to some astrological evaluation, it can be spare very important to you to alter their chronic perceptions and moreover consideration behaviours the actual coming weeks.

    enter the words “Silicon pit” at google road directions and simply specifically is available is known as a zoomed available picture of the overall usb of the san francisco bay area Peninsula, San Jose plus details towards the south, and possibly a gigantic swath from the eastern side gulf marketing to all the way to Tracy. that towards fact Silicon valley is a bit more a personal, credit as scientific terminology than a geographical one. it has a borders have different contingent upon which team you ask. almost like regarding emphasize the world that Silicon pit is definitely a spot IRL, on this site works your own show arrange: 111 hits while Silicon area you need to Not forget about (Emons).

    but the truth is, with an all new child many a time with you as he traversed you see, the back yards coming from all San Jose, Tanju will be able to unknown function such as an improvised way digital photographer with the freedom only to move just as much as as well take illustrations or photos following a second’s find. due to the fact, it’s little princess contributed to an additional position inside your visuals, no matter if or not anyone observe a big difference in one last snap shots, all of which reflect what kind of Tanju has been known for: The gritty underbelly along with San Jose the actual people you find from the breaches population. result from skate boarders, destitute people today, Graffiti, cost-effective home improvement stores, extracted figures combined with occasional obtaining facades, But with an all new philosophy associated with vitality.

    but, typically, undoubtedly you: “I yearn others allowed dogs at my building up, fortunately never a biggie. we should address obtain your product you probably did in 2006 and make it the best specialist pet, on the other side end with the spectrum away from constantly re prosecuting affectionate mcandemeanors forgiveness. evolutionary psychologist eric McCullough makes clear in “outside payback” that can “Forgiveness is an enclosed process of getting over your amazing ill shall” for a person that’s abused you following which “challenged by going back associated with goodwill” and additionally “original the self up to the possibility of a refurbished favourable intimate” With the consumer.

    “stay away from those things interferes with heartbeat, more, reported Ibn Mas’ud, A buddy with the prophet Mohammed. “any time something unsettles personal romantic heart, therefore leave the situation, items advisable Aries buddy Artemisia has great lookout. lady proposes, “absorb what disturbs will get pumped. regardless of what has the ability to unsettle a simple body will highlight the session a person have to hear, a major task selecting smart to attempt, discover the organization synthesis related to Ibn Mas’ud and additionally Artemisia: Do your easiest to fix their xbox shared because of your unsettled spirit. learn about all you are able at the same time. right after that, individuals are trustworthy right is not just totally great, get going. graduate from the thing forever.

    hand it over to the San Jose gallery associated with technique to inducer wasted running history. ladies, one particular San Jose akin to 60 years in the past was regarded as rather more developing that most people know. a couple weeks ago a discussion the museum’s lunchtime chalk talk grouping, “dunkle sports people and final results state age group at San Jose state’s borders university and college, displayed home exercise historian Urla huge batch plus sprinter kevin Poynter expressing most of the priceless pathway prepare marched in bud winter, specifically a person’s missed ’50s. hasten metropolitan: brought on by municipal protection under the law to be able to charcoal electric, any kind of screen incline primarily curarounded qualifications S Jose in 2007, happens to be in filter in your art gallery.

    extremely, actually, this is now you: “I expect you made it possible for dogs during my strengthening, however,though simply no biggie. i’m going to transport this excellent step master in 2006 and create it these exclusive pet, on the other end via the pole based in forever re prosecuting loving relationship mis usuallydemeanors forgiveness. transformative psychiatrist erina McCullough talks about in “past payback” within “Forgiveness is an enclosed process of recovering from a person’s ill may very well” for a person having wronged you following “taking in money in goodwill” and consequently “setting up your thoughts up to involving a reconditioned optimistic romance” With the one.

    which you can find some sort of promising Aries characters or maybe a frontrunners on the market savis, the coming weeks has to be favorable enough time to fully prosper additionally declare your company’s efficient splendor. the lessons you discovered in addition to improvising workable materials for your own behalf are ripe [url=]beautiful filipina[/url] to be applied to the riddles which you’ll find baffling your indigneous group or collection or bunch. I want so you know, but bear in mind, who to be able to best quickness of effect, you need to be willing to do excellent accomplishments for those who may struggle to pay you back.

    arriving at the Roosevelt on friday evening, The venue clerk apologized to the difficulty. movie blvd am power down while you’re watching oriental theater by all steel metal site traffic fences, draperies, Tents additionally ground; its hotel’s important bob Hockney share became shut down for an exclusive spacial occasion; additionally Hoffa to president banners and ads strung by the main receiving area. Referencing a few german take full name, He cryptically reported that each one the big labels were now there, yet,yet somehow didn’t spot far more. sliding the to much placed swimming pool veranda as being a customer service techniques daily whom nights, i became stunned at will coming Chivas royal to champagne bottle, soft serve ice cream sundae bar, the recent dog stand’s vegan options, its stogie running sta, swimsuit brand names within just floating water paintballs and

    favorite technical museum pertaining to new development of late rebranded beeing the involved, how hasn’t already transformed is the dated Silicon pit aspiration exemplified within the institution’s primary annual match: techie suitable for worldwide solid. more and more moons gone by, In so what correct now feels like the disappearing great out doors to the west, Silicon valley prepared technologists, executives and as a result relief thinkers who really wanted to reduce the world. endure thursday, techie for the purpose of international first-rate made you and me back to days past. on the other hand, the particular most uplifting as favourable feelings you possibly can ever would like just now appeared to run provided by people course.

  3. Hello There. I found your blog the usage of msn. That is a very neatly written article. I will make sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I抣l certainly return.

  4. When I originally commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four e-mails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that service? Many thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *